C# Како прв програмски јазик - Да или Не ?

Лутајќи по нет, барав нешто за C# и случано налетав на многу интересна дискусија за свите програмери и почетници и професионалци.

Дискусијата е за дали C# e добар јазик за почетник , зошто според многу као демек ќе те научел на лоши навике и нема да бидеш добар програмер ( ГЛУПОСT )




Прашањето :

I know there are similar questions on here, which I've read, but I recently read this post by Joel Spolsky:

How can I teach a bright person, with no programming experience, how to program?

And it got me thinking about my way of learning and whether it might actually be harmful in the long run.

I've dabbled with various languages but C# is my first serious one, I've read "Head First C#" and created a few projects. But after reading the post above I've found it a bit disheartening that I may be going about it all wrong, obviously I respect Joel's opinion which is what has thrown me a bit.

I've started reading "Code" as recommended in the reading list and I'm finding it pretty hard going, although enjoyable. I feel like it's taken the shine off of my "noobish hacking about" in Visual Studio.

So now I'm unsure as to what path I should take? Should I take a step back and follow Joel's advice and start reading?

I guess my main aim is just to become a good programmer, like everyone else, but I don't want to be going into bad practice by learning a .NET language when someone who's opinion I respect thinks that it is harmful.

Thoughts?

Линк до постот : http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/100488/is-learning-c-as-a-first-language-a-mistake

Според мене најкомплетен одговор со кој се согласуем целосно

Значи целата поента не е битно со кој јазик ќе почнеш битно е да се доусовршуеш цело време и со  самата потреба и искуство ќе те натера да совладаш и други јазици доколку неможеш задачата да ја извршиш у тој .

Дефинитивно не е битно со кој јазик ќе почнеш да учиш програмирање битно е да почнеш :

I've dabbed with various languages but C# is my first serious one, I've read "Head First C#" and created a few projects. But after reading the post above I've found it a bit disheartening that I may be going about it all wrong, obviously I respect Joel's opinion which is what has thrown me a bit.

I respect Joel's opinions too, but they are just that: opinions. There's absolutely nothing wrong with using C# as a starting language.

The biggest advice I can give you, or anyone doing any programming (even if they're starting in vanilla C!) is to not be stagnant, and don't be religious. I don't care what programming language you're starting with, or how pure or righteous that language is - in this day and age you cannot afford to sit in only world of programming.

For example, I started programming with PHP3 back when I was a teenager. I built some small web apps and a few web sites with it; I thought that I was a genius programmer and that I could doanything with PHP3, and frowned on people who were all about ASP or BASIC. Boy, was I wrong.

I didn't start to truly blossom as a developer until I began expanding my horizons and studying other programming languages and concepts. During high school I learned some RealBASIC, and then later Visual Basic. After business school, when I became a professional developer, I started learning C# and Javascript in earnest.

Now, don't misunderstand me here - I'm not advocating that you try to be a Jack of All Trades. At heart, and in trade, I'm still a PHP programmer. PHP is my bread and butter, and I know it inside and out. However, my PHP skills didn't become what they were just doing PHP. Here are some highly important concepts that I didn't grasp from PHP, despite working in it professionaly.

• Javascript: Closures
• jQuery (yes, separate): the DOM and Ajax
• Visual Basic: Objected-oriented programming
• C#: Generics and closures
• Ruby (on Rails): The power of MVC design

I could go on, and so could many others on this site as well, for days. Even though I'm a PHP programmer I was able to bring all of these other wonderful concepts back with me into the work I do every day.

What's my point? Learn C#. Become a master of C# - you'll have a long, successful career and you'll probably accomplish some amazing things. But don't pigeon-hole yourself. Journey, and taste other languages and environments and concepts.

http://programmers.stackexchange.com/a/100502